Back Pain After Your Accident? Here's Why "Just Back Pain" Might Be Selling You Short

If your back hurts AND you have pain, numbness, or tingling going down your leg, that's not just "back pain." It could be nerve damage—and the difference in your settlement could be $50,000 or more.

Why Does "Low Back Pain" Get Such Low Offers?

Here's the frustrating truth: "low back pain" is one of the most common diagnoses after accidents—and one of the most undervalued.

The problem is that the code M54.5 ("low back pain") doesn't tell anyone what's actually wrong. It just says your back hurts. And since back pain is something millions of people deal with, insurance adjusters treat it like it's no big deal.

What they'll say: "Back pain? Everyone has back pain. Here's $8,000."

What might actually be going on: A disc pressing on a nerve. Torn ligaments. Damage to the joints in your spine. Real structural injuries that deserve real compensation.

Why does this happen? Emergency rooms are busy—they're focused on making sure you don't have a broken spine, not on giving you a detailed diagnosis. Your regular doctor might use simple codes because that's what they're used to. And if no one specifically asks about leg symptoms, nerve involvement might never get documented.

The result? You could have a significant injury that's being treated like a minor complaint.

Do You Have Leg Symptoms Too? That Changes Everything

This is the key question: Is your pain ONLY in your back, or do you also have symptoms going down your leg?

If you have leg symptoms—pain shooting down your leg, numbness, tingling, or weakness—that's a sign of nerve involvement. Doctors call this "radiculopathy" or "sciatica." And it's a completely different situation than just back pain.

Here's why it matters for your claim:

Back pain only (M54.5): Insurance sees this as minor. Typical offers: $5,000 - $20,000.

Back pain WITH nerve involvement (M54.16): This is documented nerve damage. Typical range: $40,000 - $150,000+.

Same accident. Same person. But if your records show nerve involvement, your claim is worth significantly more.

The problem is that if you don't specifically tell your doctor about leg symptoms, they might not ask. And if they don't ask, it doesn't get documented. And if it's not documented, it's like it never happened—at least as far as your claim is concerned.

What Does Sciatica Actually Feel Like?

If you're not sure whether you have nerve involvement, here's what to look for:

The classic sciatica pattern: Pain that starts in your lower back or buttock and shoots down the back of your leg. It might go all the way to your foot. Often, the leg pain is actually worse than the back pain.

Nerve-specific symptoms: Numbness in specific areas—like the outside of your calf or the top of your foot. Tingling or "pins and needles." Weakness—like your foot feels heavy or you have trouble walking on your toes or heels. Burning sensations or feelings like electric shocks.

What makes it worse: Sitting for a long time. Bending forward. Coughing or sneezing (this is a big one—if coughing makes your leg hurt, that's a nerve sign). Certain positions.

Here's the important part: if you're experiencing any of these symptoms, tell your doctor specifically. Don't just say "my back hurts." Say "my back hurts AND I have numbness going down my leg" or "my back hurts AND I get shooting pain when I sit too long." Those details matter.

What Evidence Makes a Back Injury Claim Stronger?

Insurance companies don't just take your word for it. They want proof. Here's what actually moves the needle:

Objective test results: An MRI showing a disc pressing on a nerve. An EMG (nerve conduction study) showing the nerve isn't working right. A doctor's exam showing specific areas of numbness or weakness. These are things that can be measured and documented—they're not just you saying you hurt.

Treatment that matches the injury: If you have nerve involvement, you should be seeing specialists, not just your regular doctor. Physical therapy, injections, maybe a surgical consultation. The treatment path tells a story about how serious your injury is.

Documentation of how it affects your life: Can you do your job? Can you sleep through the night? Can you pick up your kids? Can you exercise? These real-life impacts matter. Get them documented—work restrictions from your doctor, notes about activities you can't do anymore.

Consistency: Your symptoms should be the same story everywhere—what you tell your doctor, what you tell the physical therapist, what your MRI shows. If there are contradictions or big gaps in your treatment, insurance will use that against you.

The formula is simple: Objective findings + consistent symptoms + appropriate treatment + real-life impact = a stronger claim.

Injury Code Scanner

Select where it hurts to see potential ICD-10 codes in your medical records.

Understanding ICD-10 Code M54.5

M54.5 - Low back pain. This is the generic code doctors use when your lower back hurts. The problem? It doesn't tell anyone WHY it hurts. Insurance companies love this code because it sounds like something everyone has—and they can offer you less money because of it.

How much is a back injury case worth?

It varies a lot depending on what's actually wrong. Generic "low back pain" cases often settle for $8,000-$25,000. But if you have documented nerve involvement (radiculopathy/sciatica), that range jumps to $40,000-$150,000. Cases requiring surgery can exceed $200,000. The key factor is whether nerve damage is documented in your records.

What's the difference between back pain and sciatica?

Back pain stays in your back. Sciatica (radiculopathy) involves a pinched nerve that causes symptoms down your leg—shooting pain, numbness, tingling, or weakness. The distinction matters a lot for your claim because nerve involvement is considered more serious and is worth more.

Can nerve damage from a back injury be permanent?

It can be. If a nerve is compressed for too long or too severely, the damage may not fully heal even with treatment. Some people end up with permanent numbness, weakness, or pain. The longer you wait to get treatment, the higher the risk of lasting damage.

The insurance company says my back pain is "just soft tissue." What does that mean?

They're trying to minimize your injury. "Soft tissue" sounds minor, but it's actually a broad term that includes muscles, ligaments, and nerves. A pinched nerve is technically a soft tissue injury—and it's not minor at all. What matters is the specific diagnosis in your records and whether nerve involvement is documented.

How do I prove my back injury was caused by the accident?

The key is connecting the dots: you got medical treatment soon after the accident, you've been consistent about your symptoms, your imaging shows something that could have been caused by trauma, and you didn't have these problems before. If there are big gaps in your treatment or your story keeps changing, that makes it harder to prove.

Get Your Personalized Settlement Estimate

Our AI analyzes your specific injury codes and compares them to 50,000+ resolved cases. Know your true value in under 5 minutes.